Superficially Improving Google Reader

This is really a post about adapting Helvetireader for netbook-sized screens, but I can’t resist adding a short rant about online RSS aggregators first…

Why Google Reader?

Once upon a time, on the recommendation of Need To Know, I started using Bloglines to keep track of blogs and anything else that published an RSS feed.  It worked pretty well, but had a number of usability problems that were fixed by the excellent Bloglines Beta.  Well, it was excellent apart from one thing: at some point (one or two years ago?) feeds stopped being updated in a timely fashion.  I reported this as a bug but, in contrast to all my previous bug reports to them, I never even received a confirmation email back.  Problems of this type have been widely reported but as far as I know this is still unfixed.  Unfortunately, while I loved the interface of Bloglines Beta this lack of updates meant that it had effectively become useless, so I’ve switched to Google Reader – the other reasonable alternative when I was considering a switch seemed to be “NewsGator Online“, but that failed to import my rather large list of feeds and the service has now shut down anyway.

It’s very sad that Bloglines’s previously excellent service seems to be now so unloved by its current owners and maintainers.

Google Reader’s Shortcomings

(Update: originally this paragraph had a short complaint about how Google Reader couldn’t be configured in a way that I was happy with, but then Jenny pointed out that in fact it could :)  In short, the following settings are the ones that I like:

  • Select “New Items”, which is a toggle for the view, applying to everything until you change it back to “All Items”.
  • (Tedious) Go to every feed and folder in the subscription list on the left and select from the drop-down menus “Sort by oldest”.

Annoyingly the “Sort by oldest” option then only shows the unread items in the last 30 days, ordered chronologically – but this is still much better than the default configuration, in my opinion.)

There are also some superficial annoyances that fortunately can be easily fixed:

  • The appearance of the page is noisy and inelegant.
  • The layout works badly on small screens, such as my netbook.

At some point I was told about Jon Hicks’s “Helvetireader” redesign of the CSS for Google reader.  This is a vast improvement in the appearance of the application, I think, and it hides much of the noise in the interface that I don’t care about – for example, here are some “before and after” screenshots:

screenshot-basic

And with Helvetireader:screenshot-helvetireaderHowever this still uses up a lot of screen real estate at the top of the page for elements that I don’t care about, such as the search box, login details, social features, etc.  Also, on my netbook the pane on the left is so large that you can’t get a single Dinosaur Comics visible in the right :)  So I added a few more instances of display: none to the Helvetireader CSS and adjusted the sizes of the main panes.  The only non-obvious bit about this was that there’s some bit of Google’s javascript that sets the display property of the search box back to block – fortunately, if you use Greasemonkey to change the ID of this element to something else, then it can’t be found by ID and changed back.  This is a bit horrible, but doesn’t seem to obviously break anything else in the interface…screenshot-helvetireader-reducedIf you want to try this out, then the Greasemonkey script is here, and that points to the CSS here.  Those are tracked in a github gist in case you want to see all the changes back to the original Helvetireader.  This works well in Chromium (so presumably Google Chrome too) and is OK in Firefox, but for an odd bug where the window doesn’t redraw correctly after changing the CSS – you can resize the window to force a redraw, though.

Update: the screenshot there shows a slightly older version of my customization – since then I’ve added back some options for feed settings, etc.

I rather like this approach to changing the appearance of websites to match your needs.  You can find many inventive examples of this idea at userstyles.org.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.